Research Article |
Academic editor: David C. Lees
© 2021 Wolfram Mey, Théo Léger, Vu Van Lien.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Mey W, Léger T, Lien VV (2021) Extant and fossil records of currently Australian primitive moths in South-East Asia and their biogeographic significance (Lepidoptera, Micropterigidae, Agatiphagidae, Lophocoronidae). Nota Lepidopterologica 44: 29-56. https://doi.org/10.3897/nl.44.52350
|
We report some surprising recent distributional range extensions of one extant genus and two more families of primitive moths discovered in amber fossils from South-east Asia which were previously only known from Australia and/or the southwestern Pacific, with the possible exception of an undescribed Siberian fossil attributed to Lophocoronidae. During entomological field work in rain forests of central Vietnam a new species of Micropterigidae was discovered. It is described herein as Aureopterix bachmaensis sp. nov. based on male and female specimens collected at light in the Bach-Ma National Park. The identification was corroborated by a molecular analysis. This is the first record of this genus in the Northern Hemisphere, previously thought to be restricted to the Australian Region (including New Caledonia). First results of investigations of Burmese amber inclusions now reveal the presence of the Australian Region families Agathiphagidae and Lophocoronidae in the Cretaceous of Asia. The fossil taxon Agathiphagama perdita gen. nov., sp. nov. is established on the basis of two females and this is assigned to Agathiphagidae. The fossil genus Acanthocorona gen. nov. is established in Lophocoronidae and includes seven species described here as A. skalskii sp. nov., A. bowangi sp. nov., A. muelleri sp. nov., A. kuranishii sp. nov., A. sattleri sp. nov., A. spinifera sp. nov. and A. wichardi sp. nov. The new species can be distinguished by the male genitalia which are illustrated together with wing venation and other morphological characters. The disjunct ranges of these taxa are discussed in a historical biogeographic context. Vicariance and dispersal hypotheses explaining the disjunct pattern are discussed. The discovery of these new species suggests a broader ancestral range of Aureopterix, Agathiphagidae and Lophocoronidae. Their extant ranges may be regarded as remnants or relicts of a wider distribution in the Mesozoic, or at least in the case of Aureopterix they could be the results of recent or ancient dispersal processes, since the calibration of molecular splits does not so far accord with plate tectonics.
In continental South-East Asia the faunas of the Eastern Palaearctic and Oriental Regions share a common border. This borderline is not a clear-cut delimitation and separation of both faunas, but rather a broad transition zone extending from the slopes of the southern Himalayas in northern India to northern Myanmar, Thailand, Laos, Vietnam and southern China including Taiwan (
Micropterigidae : Micropterix Hübner, 1825, Paramartyria Issiki, 1931, Vietomartyria Hashimoto & Mey, 2000
Eriocraniidae : Eriocrania Zeller, 1850, unpublished record (in coll. MfN)
Hepialoidea : Ogygioses Issiki & Stringer, 1932
Neopseustidae : Neopseustis Meyrick, 1909, Nematocentropus Hwang, 1965
A common feature of primitive moths is the low number of collected specimens for the majority of species. The species are rarely encountered in nature, and almost every new record merits communication. The scarcity of hitherto found specimens, however, suggests the occurrence of further relict species. Concerning Microlepidoptera, continental South East Asia has not been sufficiently explored, and new discoveries remain to be made, particularly in the mountain ranges of the Palaearctic-Oriental transition zone.
During the first field trip of the joint Vietnamese-German project VIETBIO to Central Vietnam in 2018, the first author was searching for caddisflies and micromoths in the Bach-Ma National Park (
Closer inspections of the specimens identified them as belonging to Aureopterix Gibbs, 2010, a genus reported so far only from Australia and New Caledonia (
Examination of insect inclusions in Burmese amber resulted in the discovery of individuals which were identified as putative species of Agathiphagidae and Lophocoronidae. Both families are currently regarded as extant, endemic families of Australia and Southwest Pacific Islands. Interestingly,
The adult moths were pinned and set in the field. Genitalia drawings were performed prior to embedding in Euparal on a genitalia slide. A camera lucida attached to a Leica MZ12 compound microscope was used. Genital preparations were made according to the procedure described in
DNA extraction were performed with a NucleoSpin Tissue kit (Macherey-Nagel, Düren, Germany). The standard forward and reverse primers LCO/Nancy for the DNA barcode region failed at amplifying the target region. The COI barcode was thus amplified in two parts refered to as COI fragment 1a and 1b, using primers from
Sequences were eye-checked under PhyDE 0.9971 (
Photos of fossil species were taken using a Leica stereomicroscope M 420 Apozoom in combination with a Canon EOS 80D, EOS utility software and the Zerene Stacker software.
The fossils were examined under incident and transmitted light using a stereomicroscope (Leica MZ125). Line drawings were produced with a Leica camera lucida and digitally processed using Adobe Photoshop CS4. Measurements were made with the ocular micrometer of the stereomicroscope.
All taxonomic acts established in the present work have been registered in ZooBank, together with the electronic publication: http://zoobank.org/FC32D2F4-5EE1-4484-8BAF-D873487DB332.
The terminology of genitalia structures used in the descriptions of taxa follows
AMNH American Museum of Natural History, New York
TF ex coll. Thilo Fischer, München
PM ex coll. Patrick Müller, Käshofen (will be transferred to MfN later)
MfN Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin
NIGP Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology, Nanjing, P.R. of China
VNMN Vietnam National Museum of Nature, Hanoi.
Holotype ♂, Vietnam, Thua Thien-Hue Province, Bach-Ma National Park, 12.vi.2018, above Rhododendron Trail, 1256 m, 16°11.757'N, 107°50.922'E, at light, leg. W. Mey, genitalia slide Mey 08/20, DNA voucher Lepidoptera, MFN LEP042 (VNMN).
Paratypes : 2 ♀, Vietnam, Thua Thien-Hue Province, Bach-Ma National Park, 10.vi.2018, Five Lakes Trail, 1190 m, 16°12.214'N, 107°50.441'E, at light, leg. W. Mey, genitalia slide Mey 09/20, 1 ♀ in alcohol, DNA voucher Lepidoptera, MFNLEP041 (MfN).
The specific name is derived from the name of the Bach-Ma National Park.
Vietnam. Male with long genitalia, projecting half the length of abdomen in dried specimens; abdomen and genitalia with long, scattered setae; tergum X of males with single setal tuft on each ventro-lateral margin on a raised base at mid-length.
Forewing ground colour and fascial pattern (Figs
(Figs
Male genitalia
(Figs
Female genitalia
(Fig.
(Fig.
The locality in the Bach-Ma National Park will probably not remain the only record of this new species. Future field work will provide a more accurate picture of the species range, which is probably restricted to the Truong Son Mountain Range (= Annamite Range). This roughly north to south running mountain range along the Laos-Vietnam border is an area of endemism which gained global recognition in the early to mid-1990s with the discovery of six spectacular mammal species (
Adults of Aureopterix bachmaensis sp. nov. and their phylogenetic placement. A. Male, holotype; B. Female, paratype; C. Phylogenetic tree of Aureopterix. Best scoring RAxML-tree with node calibration in millions of years displayed above branches. Sabatinca branch not represented for visual convenience.
Aureopterix bachmaensis sp. nov.; 3–5. Head, female; 3. Dorsal view; 4. Frontal view, right maxillary palpus omitted; 5. Lateral view; 6. Flagellomeres, mid-section; 7. Wing venation, holotype; 8. Male abdomen and genitalia, lateral view; 9. Segment X, dorsal view; 10. Male genitalia, ventral view; 11. Female abdomen, lateral view. Scale bars: 0.25 mm (3–5.); 10 µm (6.); 1 mm (7.); 0.5 mm (8.); 0.5 mm (10., 11.);
Agathiphagama perdita sp. nov., Gender: feminine.
Composed of the generic name Agathiphaga and the added syllable “ma”.
Burmese amber, middle-sized species, terminal segments of maxillary palpi annulated, basal segment of labial palpi with dorsal hair-brush, tibial spurs 1.3.4., epiphysis present on short foretibia, forewings with R1 shortly branched into R1a and R1b, female with long, telescoping ovipositor, apophyses posteriores fused in apical half into a single apophysis extending in midline towards slender papillae anales.
The fossil genus differs from extant homoneurous moths of Agathiphaga Dumbleton, 1952 by differences in the morphology of the maxillary and labial palpi, the spur formula 1.3.4. (1.4.4. in Agathiphaga) and the long, fused terminal part of the apophyses posteriores (shorter in Agathiphaga).
The flexible form of the terminal segment of the maxillary palpi seems to be due to a mottled loss of sclerotization, which gives the segment an annulated appearance. In Agathiphaga, this segment is very short and not annulated (
The new genus is here assigned to Agathiphagidae. An alternative placement considered was the establishment of a new family as sister to Agathiphagidae in Agathiphagoidea. However, there is presently insufficient morphological basis to establish a new family.
See description of A. perdita sp. nov. below.
Holotype ♀, Burmese amber, NIGP 173715, (NIGP); paratype ♀, # 7095 (TF).
The specific name is the Latin adjective “perditus”, lost, in singular, feminine nominative, referring to the species as an extinct taxon.
The holotype is embedded in a large, polished and oval piece of amber (Fig.
Length of forewings 10.2 mm, head capsule extending far above eyes (Fig.
Female genitalia
(Fig.
This is the first fossil species of the family. It is also the first evidence of the occurrence of the family Agathiphagidae in South-East Asia in the Mesozoic about 100 Ma ago. The morphological differences to Agathiphaga are significant and justify at least the establishment of a separate genus. According to
The fossil Agathiphagama gen. nov. and the extant Agathiphaga are the only genera of Agathiphagidae. Both genera exhibit the characters of the family, but are probably not closely related due to the differences indicated in the diagnosis. The annulated terminal segments of the maxillary palpi of Agathiphagama gen.nov. seems to be a derived character. It resembles the terminal maxillary palpi of Annulipalpia and some Integripalpia genera (e.g. Athripsodes Billberg, 1820, Ceraclea Stephens, 1829) in Trichoptera.
The Agathiphagidae are the only known family in extant Lepidoptera with four veins in the forewings including remarkable variation in branching pattern (
K2P distances between DNA barcode sequences of Aureopterix species. GenBank accession numbers are appended to each sample.
Species | MFNLEP41 | MFNLEP42 | MICOW073-09 |
---|---|---|---|
MFNLEP41|Aureopterix_bachmaensis|COI-5P|LR961636 | |||
MFNLEP42|Aureopterix_bachmaensis|COI-5P|LR961637 | 0.68% | ||
MICOW073-09|Aureopterix_sterops|COI-5P|HM431791 | 12.42% | 11.79% | |
MICOW398-10|Aureopterix_micans|COI-5P|HQ575019 | 12.77% | 11.74% | 14.44% |
Acanthocorona spp.: 18–20. A. skalskii sp. nov.: 18. Wing venation; 19. Male genitalia, ventral; 20. Male genitalia, dorsal; 21. A. muelleri sp. nov., male genitalia, ventral, 22. A. bowangi sp. nov., male genitalia, ventral; 23. A. wichardi sp. nov., ventral; 24. A. kuranishi sp. nov., ventro-caudal, 25. A. sattleri sp. nov., male genitalia; A – ventro-lateral, B – dorso-lateral. Scale bars: 1 mm (18.); 0.5 mm (20., 22., 23., 25.).
26–30. Acanthocorona spinifera sp. nov.: 26. Male genitalia, dorsal; 27. Ventral; 28. Legs; 29. Forewing scales; 30. Wing venation; 31. Acanthocorona sp., female (NIGP 173719), postabdomen, ventro-lateral view, and oviscapt tip, dorsal view. Scale bars: 0.5 mm (28.); 1 mm (30.); 0.8 mm (31.).
Acanthocorona skalskii sp. nov., Gender: feminine.
A noun composed of the Latin “acanthus”, thorn and the Latin “corona”, crown, alluding to the name Lophocorona and to the long spikes at the bases of the valvae and the spine and denticules on its apical margins, forming a spiny crown when the tips of the valvae are hold close together.
Burmese amber, small-sized species, antennae short, basal flagellomeres broad, epiphysis present, homoneurous venation, forewings with accessory and median cells present, cross-vein r1-r2 present, R5 running to termen (below apex) in both wings; valvae of male genitalia with one or more pairs of long, basal spikes and a terminal, short, rod-like ‘thorn'.
This fossil genus differs from extant homoneurous moths of Lophocorona by the presence of an epiphysis (absent in Lophocorona), the presence of crossvein r1-r2 and the joint presence of an accessory and median cell (accessory cell may be present or absent in Lophocorona). The valvae in the male genitalia carry a long, rod-like spine on the ventral tip together with numerous short denticules on the apical margin. In Lophocorona the spine on the ventral tip is small and blunt. The long spikes originating from the inner side of the base of the valvae can be regarded a synapomorphy of Lophocorona and Acanthocorona gen. nov.
Forewing length 3–5 mm, eyes hemispherical, frons and vertex with tufts of long piliform scales, ocelli absent; antennae short, about half the length of forewings, about 25–30 flagellomeres present, flagellomeres scaled on dorsal side, wider than long at base, becoming thinner and slender towards tip of antennae; proboscis present, dissociated into galea halves, maxillary palpi reduced in size, labial palpi upturned, terminal segment swollen, densely clothed by short bristles, tibial spurs 0.2.4., spurs covered by small scales, epiphysis present, legs slender (Fig.
Male genitalia
(Figs
Female genitalia
(Fig.
Diagnostic characters of Lophocorona Common, 1973 are: 1) absence of an epiphysis, and 2) the long stalk of R4 and R5 in the forewings encompassing the wing apex. These characters are in a plesiomorphic state in Acanthocorona gen nov., with epiphysis present and R4 and R5 in the forewings always running as separate veins from accessory cell to wing margin. However, the structures of the male and female genitalia agree largely with those of Lophocorona. Especially the architecture of the female postabdomen is very similar to those of females of extant Lophocorona species (
Burmese amber contains a surprisingly high number of species attributable to Acanthocorona gen. nov. The individuals are in most cases embedded in an unfavourable position and exhibit only a reduced number of characters. But none of the externally visible traits contradict the diagnosis and description of the genus. Cross-veins are often difficult to see and they may appear to be absent in some individuals. This uncertainty makes the character unreliable and reduces its taxonomic weight. The following species are described and included in Acanthocorona gen. nov. essentially on the basis of the male genitalia. The morphology and arrangements of spines and denticules on apical parts of the valvae constitute the principal character complex, which exhibits a large variety allowing the separation and establishment of different species. The following descriptions of new species are short and concentrate on the male genitalia and their illustrations. The depicted features are diagnostic enough to distinguish the presented species and to identify new species in fresh, additional material of Burmese amber, which hopefully will continue to become available for scientific study in the future.
Holotype ♂, Burmese amber, NIGP 173716, (NIGP).
The species is named in memory of Andrzej Skalski, who published the first record of a lophocoronid specimen from Asia (
Completely preserved in a nearly rectangular piece of amber, wings somewhat spread, but overlapping, head, legs and postabdomen clearly visible (Fig.
Length of forewings 4.1 mm, antennae dark brown, with 29 flagellomeres; wing venation (Fig.
Male genitalia
(Figs
Holotype ♂, Burmese amber, BUB 1519, (PM).
The species is named in honour of Patrick Müller, collector of amber inclusions, for providing material for scientific study.
Completely preserved in a flat, oval piece of amber (Fig.
Length of forewings 3.0 mm, antennae brown, 23 flagellomeres.
Male genitalia
(Figs
Holotype ♂, Burmese amber, BUB 1519, (PM).
The species is named in honour of Bo Wang for his efforts to make Burmese amber material available for scientific study.
Completely preserved on the margin in a large, drop-like piece of amber, wings somewhat overlapping, distorted, legs and post-abdomen clearly visible.
Length of forewings 3.6 mm, antennae dark brown, 24 flagellomeres.
Male genitalia (Fig.
Holotype ♂, Burmese amber, NIGP 173717 (NIGP).
The species is named in honour of Wilfried Wichard for providing material and taking photos of Microlepidoptera of Burmese amber.
Completely preserved in an oval piece of amber with much particulate detritus particles and some air bubbles, wings overlapping, legs and post-abdomen clearly visible in ventral view, one additional insect specimen present (one female of Hydroptilidae, Trichoptera, a single minute Coleoptera).
Length of forewings 3.8 mm, antennae light brown, 24 flagellomeres, long spines on legs absent.
Male genitalia
(Fig.
A. wichardi sp. nov. differs from the remaining species of the genus by lacking spines on the legs, absence of basal spikes and apical, rod-like spines of the valvae. The presence of a long spine on the median side of the valvae instead of emerging on the ventral corner is a unique character. The species is provisionally included in the genus until better preserved material becomes available which may lead to a different systematic placement.
Holotype ♂, Burmese amber, MB.I. 5484, (MfN).
The species is named in honour of Ryoichi Kuranishi (Chiba, Japan), who generously donated the amber piece with the inclusion to W. Mey and the MfN.
Completely preserved in a round, polished piece of amber, but not clearly visible due to several fractures in the amber; numerous small bubbles of air present; wings overlapping, legs and postabdomen clearly visible.
Length of forewings 4.0 mm, antennae light brown, 25 flagellomeres, legs with strong spines.
Male genitalia
(Fig.
Holotype ♂, Burmese amber, BUB 570, (PM); paratype ♂, Burmese amber, James Ziegras Collection, JZC – Bu 203 (AMNH).
The species is named in honour of Klaus Sattler, London, specialist of Microlepidoptera in the Natural History Museum, London, for his support and help during many visits of the first author to the Microlepidoptera collection in London.
Completely preserved in a flat, rounded and polished piece of amber, numerous small bubbles of air and two, minute midges (Diptera) present; wings overlapping, head, legs and postabdomen clearly visible in ventral view.
Length of forewings 2.9 mm, antennae light brown, very short, about 0.3 of forewing length, with 21 flagellomeres.
Male genitalia
(Fig.
Holotype ♂, Burmese amber, NIGP 173718, (NIGP).
The specific epithet is composed from Latin “spina”, spine, and “fero”, to carry, referring to the strong spines on tibiae of the adult moth.
Completely preserved in a small, rounded, polished piece of amber, embedded in dorso-ventral position, with right wings spread out, some short fractures and few a bubbles of air present, legs and postabdomen well visible (Fig.
Length of forewings 4.8 mm, antennae dark brown, less than 0.5 of forewing length, with 30 flagellomeres; scales of forewing short and spatulate, or long with apical margin serrated, scales of fringes long, lanceolate, rounded at apex (Fig.
Male genitalia
(Figs
1 ♀, Burmese amber, NIGP 173719, (NIGP); 1 ♀, # 7098 (TF).
Length of forewings 3.4–4.2 mm, antennae pale brown, about 0.3 of forewing length, with 22–25 flat flagellomeres; labial palpi larger than maxillary palpi, terminal segment bulbous with long bristles, proboscis small; epiphysis present, legs with spines and scaled spurs; wing venation homoneurous, R5 to termen.
Female genitalia
(Fig.
These female specimens cannot be assigned to any of the named species at the moment (see under remarks in the genus description). Since the female genitalia is an important character complex for the recognition of the family, the genitalia of one individual (NIGP 173719) was illustrated. The genitalia of the second species are difficult to see but are identifiable as those of a female.
This paper aims to complete the picture of the distribution and diversity of past and recent primitive moths. A formal biogeographic analysis or providing a comprehensive review of recent and past distributions was beyond the scope of this study. The following discussion aims to guide any future biogeographical studies on primitive moths of South-East Asia, as well as to foster further works on Lepidoptera fossils.
Dispersal and colonization processes are closely related to the tectonic structure and geological and climate history in South East Asia, Melanesia and the Southwest Pacific. Kitching et al. (2001) and
In a molecular study of the radiation of the micropterigid genus Sabatinca Walker, 1863 in New Caledonia and New Zealand using COI-5P, both species of Aureopterix known for the Australian region were included (
The stunning discovery of extinct taxa of primitive Lepidoptera in Myanmar, which were thought to be restricted in their distribution to the Australian Region, substantially revises present notions on the historical biogeography of Lepidoptera groups. In the absence of fossil distributions, Agathiphagidae and Lophocoronidae seem like classic cases of endemism in the Australian Region. Agathiphaga has two known species and stretches across the Pacific to Solomons, Vanuatu and Fiji and is thought to have benefitted from the possibility of long diapause in drifting Agathis seeds (Upton 1994). The biology of Lophocorona, by contrast, is still unknown. The fossil species of Agathiphagidae and Lophocoronidae found in Myanmar might alternatively provide evidence of a wider ancestral distribution of the two families, if such oceanic dispersal mechanisms do not prove to be a significant transport mechanism. The hypothesis that their extant ranges in the southern Hemisphere are relicts of a previous intercontinental distribution encompassing Asia and Australia has not yet been tested.
The time of divergence for lineages leading to the families Agathiphagidae and Eriocraniidae+Lophocoronidae was estimated by
From a historical perspective, the Oriental fauna is a mixture of tropical Laurasian and Gondwanan taxa, over which is overlaid the results of dispersal processes. The collision of the Indian subcontinent into Asia in the early Eocene brought elements of the Gondwana fauna to the north and resulted in a pronounced enrichment of the biota (
Our thanks go to Bo Wang (Nanjing, Beijing), R. Kuranishi (Chiba), P. Müller (Käshofen), T. Fischer (Munich) and W. Wichard (Bonn) for providing material of Burmese amber. Robert Schreiber (Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin) performed the PCR and processed samples for sequencing. The map was prepared by Jürgen Mey. Photos of species in Burmese amber inclusions were taken by W. Wichard (Bonn). Maria Heikkilä (Helsinki) provided photos of Acanthocorona species from the AMNH, New York.
The participation of the first author in the VIETBIO project including field work in Vietnam was generously supported by the Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin, and the German project leaders C. Häuser and T. von Rintelen.
We thank J. Dunlop (Berlin) and David C. Lees for valuable suggestions on drafts of the manuscript and for correcting the English text. G. W. Gibbs (Wellington), J. Minet (Paris), M. Kozlov (Turku) and an anonymous reviewer are thanked for their constructive corrections and hints. The project is supported by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) since 2017 (grant ID: 01 DP17052).